William Afton isn’t on screen long in Five Nights at Freddy’s, but when Matthew Lillard delivers that cold, almost mocking line “I always come back” it lands like a gut punch. It’s part threat, part promise, and part Easter egg.
On its surface, it feels like a horror villain’s final taunt before the curtain falls. But fans of Scott Cawthon’s games knew instantly: this wasn’t just a throwaway. This was a bridge between the film and the decades-spanning nightmare of the FNAF lore.
Why the Line Matters in the Five Nights at Freddy’s Movie
In the film’s climax, Afton betrayed by the very animatronics he once controlled suffers a brutal springlock failure inside the Yellow Rabbit suit. Instead of begging for mercy, he doubles down on his menace. “I always come back” signals that even death won’t stop him.
It’s a classic horror move: Michael Myers gets shot and disappears, Jason rises from the lake, Jigsaw leaves tapes even after his death. Afton’s line plants him firmly in that tradition, a villain whose presence lingers whether he’s alive or not.
And it’s no accident. Back in February, Lillard revealed in an interview that he signed a three-film deal with Blumhouse. So, when Afton says he’ll be back he means it literally.
READ MORE: Only Murders in the Building Season 5 Dives Into a Mafia Mystery That Changes Everything
The Video Game Connection
For gamers, that line is déjà vu. In FNAF 3’s trailer, the chilling tagline read:
“He will come back. He always does. We have a place for him.”
Later, in Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria Simulator, Afton’s Scraptrap form directly snarls: “I always come back.” By the time he shows up as Glitchtrap or Burntrap in later entries, the phrase had evolved into a kind of catchphrase.
Hearing it in the film wasn’t just fan service it was lore confirmation. It reinforces the idea that Afton is never truly gone. Whether as a man, a suit, or digital code, he lingers like a virus you can’t uninstall.
Every Face of William Afton So Far
To really grasp the weight of “I always come back,” you have to look at how many times Afton already has:
| Alias / Form | Where It Appears |
|---|---|
| Dave Miller | FNAF novels |
| Steve Raglan | FNAF movie (cover identity) |
| Purple Guy | FNAF 2, mini-games |
| Spring Bonnie / Yellow Rabbit | Backstory / film lore |
| Springtrap | FNAF 3 |
| Scraptrap | Pizzeria Simulator |
| Glitchtrap | Help Wanted |
| Burntrap | Security Breach |
Each form is nastier, more unkillable than the last. That’s why the line feels less like bravado and more like documentation. Afton doesn’t die he mutates.
READ MORE: ‘Wednesday’ Season 2’s New Principal Brings More Than Just Firepower to Nevermore
How Afton Could Return in Future Movies
The FNAF sequel already has a built-in excuse to bring Afton back: the games did it first. Here’s how:
-
Springtrap Lives: The glowing eyes in the final shot hint Afton survived the springlock failure, much like in FNAF 3.
-
Prequel Route: If the sequel adapts FNAF 2 (which is set before the original), Lillard’s Afton could return without breaking continuity.
-
Supernatural Possession: The movie already features ghost children. There’s nothing stopping Afton from haunting animatronics or people like his Glitchtrap counterpart.
-
New Identity: Just as the games cycled through Scraptrap and Burntrap, future films could evolve Afton into a grotesque new form.
In other words, “I always come back” is less a threat and more a mission statement for the franchise.
READ MORE: Only Murders in the Building Season 5 Dives Into a Mafia Mystery That Changes Everything
Why Afton’s Line Resonates
The beauty of Afton’s quote is that it works on two levels. For casual viewers, it’s a chilling exit line. For fans, it’s a neon sign pointing toward sequels, prequels, and an ever-expanding web of lore.
It’s rare for a villain to embody a franchise so fully. Freddy Fazbear may be on the poster, but William Afton is the connective tissue the virus, the ghost, the man behind the slaughter. And if Blumhouse sticks close to the games, his promise isn’t just a line. It’s a guarantee.
Because when Afton says, “I always come back,” history tells us he’s not lying.
Stay updated with the Latest News and Stories, follow us on our social media platforms.
You can follow us on:
Stay Connected!! Join our Whatsapp Channel
