Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Cast: Who’s Back & Who’s New

Nivedita Dubey
October 26, 2025

Summary

In Mayor of Kingstown season 4, Jeremy Renner returns as Mike McLusky alongside major recurring stars.
Season 4 introduces several key characters inside and outside Anchor Bay.
New cast members include Edie Falco and Lennie James in powerful roles.

Mayor of Kingstown season 4 brings back the gritty criminal politics of Kingstown, Michigan, with several familiar characters returning — and major new players joining the conflict. Created by Taylor Sheridan and Hugh Dillon, the series has thrived since its 2021 debut thanks to an intense crime narrative and a strong ensemble cast. Here’s a full look at every new and returning character appearing in season 4.

Which Returning Actors Lead the Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Cast?

Mayor of Kingstown _ Season 4 Official Trailer _ Paramount+

Jeremy Renner as Mike McLusky

Mike McLusky is back at the center of Kingstown’s chaos. Played by Jeremy Renner (born January 7, 1971), the character continues his work as an unofficial power broker, balancing corruption and fragile alliances so crime doesn’t spill further onto the streets. Renner’s breakout performance came in The Hurt Locker, and he is widely recognized for his Marvel role as Hawkeye. His action-driven presence adds weight to Mike’s constant battle to keep Kingstown from falling apart.

Notable Projects

The Avengers — Clint “Hawkeye” Barton
The Hurt Locker — William James
The Town — James Coughlin
Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation — William Brandt
Tag — Jerry Pierce

Taylor Handley as Kyle McLusky

Kyle McLusky faces major trouble this season. Played by Taylor Handley (born June 1, 1984), the character is a Kingstown police officer and a husband and father trying to build stability. His insecurities often push him into reckless decisions — and season 4 brings serious consequences. Handley first became known for his role in The O.C., and continues to appear in TV dramas and thrillers.

Notable Projects

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning — Dean
Griselda — Billy Jensen
Chasing Mavericks — Sonny
APB — Nicholas Brandt

Hugh Dillon as Ian Ferguson

Co-creator Hugh Dillon (born May 31, 1963) returns as Ian Ferguson, a senior detective whose loyalties shift between the police force and Mike’s back-channel efforts. Dillon, known for roles in Flashpoint and Yellowstone, brings complexity to a character who operates in morally gray territory while trying to maintain control.

Notable Projects

Yellowstone — Donnie Haskell
Flashpoint — Ed Lane
Durham County — Mike Sweeney

Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Official Trailer Paramount 12 — Mayor of Kingstown _ Season 4 Official Trailer _ Paramount+

Tobi Bamtefa as Deverin “Bunny” Washington

Bunny remains one of the show’s most compelling antiheroes. Played by Tobi Bamtefa (born 1990), he leads the Crips while caring deeply for those around him. Bunny provides for his crew and keeps order, but he’s still a violent and feared gang leader. Bamtefa has appeared in UK theatre and several screen roles.

Notable Projects

The Witcher — Sir Danek
Back in Action — Agent Obasi
Tin Star — Godswill
Horrible Histories: The Movie — Severus

Hamish Allan-Headley as Robert Sawyer

Robert Sawyer remains a controversial figure in Kingstown PD. Hamish Allan-Headley (born November 27, 1981) plays the aggressive SWAT officer known for excessive force. Season 4 follows the fallout from his bridge shooting incident, with major consequences for others around him.

Notable Projects

Daredevil: Born Again — Powell
Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy — Michael Albrecht
Law & Order: SVU — Steve Mancuso

Necar Zadegan as Evelyn Foley

Assistant District Attorney Evelyn Foley returns to the conflict between law and survival. Played by Necar Zadegan (born June 20, 1982), Evelyn and Mike’s personal involvement complicates their legal and criminal clashes. Zadegan gained recognition on 24 and continues to build a dynamic TV career.

Notable Projects

24 — Dalia Hassan
Girlfriends’ Guide to Divorce — Delia Banai
Unthinkable — Jehan Younger
The Rookie — Vivian
The Electric State — Farah Bedi

Who Are the New Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Characters?

Edie Falco as Warden Nina Hobbs

New leadership hits Anchor Bay hard in season 4. Edie Falco (born July 5, 1963) joins the cast as Nina Hobbs, the no-nonsense new warden tasked with cleaning up the prison following Kareem’s brutal death. Falco is known for powerhouse performances in The Sopranos and Nurse Jackie, making her an ideal addition to the series’ tense environment.

Notable Projects

The Sopranos — Carmela Soprano
Nurse Jackie — Jackie Peyton
Avatar: The Way of Water — General Ardmore
American Crime Story — Hillary Clinton
Oz — Diane Whittlesey

Her presence creates an immediate roadblock to Mike’s influence inside the prison.

Laura Benanti as Cindy Stephens

Broadway talent Laura Benanti (born July 15, 1979) joins season 4 as Cindy Stephens, a new prison guard whose role appears poised to grow. With a Tony Award and multiple nominations, Benanti brings a strong dramatic skill set to the series.

Notable Projects

No Hard Feelings — Allison Becker
Supergirl — Alura Zor-El
Gossip Girl — Katherine “Kiki” Hope
tick, tick… BOOM! — Judy
The Detour — Edie

Though details remain limited, Cindy’s introduction hints at major involvement in future prison developments.

Lennie James as Frank Moses

Season 4 brings a dangerous new crime figure: Frank Moses. Played by Lennie James, a fan-favorite from The Walking Dead franchise, Frank makes an unforgettable first impression with a ruthless display of dominance. His arrival suggests a new wave of control struggles rising in Kingstown.

Which Supporting Characters Return in Season 4?

Mayor of Kingstown continues to build a world where nearly every character contributes to the city’s fragile power structure. Season 4 includes returning supporting cast such as:

Nishi Munshi as Tracy McLusky — Kyle’s wife and part of Mike’s closest family circle
Lane Garrison as Carney — a prison guard loyal to Mike’s interests
Nichole Galicia as Rebecca — Mike’s dedicated office assistant
Derek Webster as Stevie — another KPD officer closely tied to the McLusky brothers
Clayton Cardenas as Deputy Warden Torres — newly installed, enforcing stricter prison operations
William Guirola as Roberto Cruz — an inmate leader challenging existing gang dominance

Each plays a meaningful part as season 4 expands the turf war inside and outside the walls of Anchor Bay.

How Does Season 4 Change the Balance of Power in Kingstown?

Between a new warden, an emerging crime boss, and a weakening grasp from those who once enforced order, the show’s landscape is shifting fast. Mike’s usual channels of influence police, prison guards, even legal contacts are strained or blocked. Meanwhile, new threats rise and returning characters face higher stakes than ever.

Every character described above plays a specific part in that evolving struggle, reinforcing the ensemble-based storytelling that has driven the show’s success.