Meet the Nobody Wants This Season 2 Cast

Nivedita Dubey
October 23, 2025

Summary:

Season 2 of Nobody Wants This explores deeper character relationships beyond Joanne and Noah.
Kristen Bell and Adam Brody return as the central couple facing faith and love challenges.
New emotional arcs highlight supporting cast members and evolving family dynamics.

Season 2 of Nobody Wants This invites viewers to fall even deeper into the intertwined lives of Joanne, Noah, and their families. As Kristen Bell and Adam Brody’s onscreen chemistry continues to shine, the show broadens its focus, exploring faith, love, and identity through an expanded ensemble of characters each with their own emotional journey.

Who Leads the Nobody Wants This Cast in Season 2?

Nobody Wants This _ Season 2 Official Trailer _ Netflix

Kristen Bell and Adam Brody return as the heart of Nobody Wants This, continuing the unlikely yet compelling love story between an agnostic podcast host and a modern rabbi. Bell’s Joanne is bold, curious, and grappling with whether love can bridge belief systems. Brody’s Noah, meanwhile, is torn between faith, duty, and his feelings for a woman outside his religion.

Co-showrunner Bruce Eric Kaplan explains that Season 2 doesn’t just revisit the pair’s challenges but expands the world around them. As Joanne and Noah merge their lives, the question becomes whether love alone is enough to sustain them through their cultural and personal differences.

How Does Kristen Bell’s Joanne Evolve This Season?

Joanne enters Season 2 caught between independence and commitment. As a podcast host who prides herself on authenticity, she now faces one of the most personal decisions of her life — whether to convert to Judaism for love.

Kristen Bell describes the tension perfectly: Noah doesn’t want Joanne to change for him, yet his faith requires her conversion if their relationship is to move forward. This internal tug-of-war drives much of Joanne’s emotional arc, revealing new depths to her character and testing her sense of identity.

Previously Seen In: The Good Place, Veronica Mars, Frozen

Where to Watch Kristen Bell on Netflix: The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window

What’s Next for Adam Brody’s Rabbi Noah?

Adam Brody’s Noah continues to be the show’s moral anchor, wrestling with love, duty, and the expectations that come with being a rabbi. In Season 2, his bond with Joanne strengthens as they start to navigate shared responsibilities — hosting dinners, blending social circles, and exploring Joanne’s potential conversion.

Brody notes that Noah learns to think beyond tradition, even as he encourages Joanne to embrace stability. Their dynamic showcases the delicate balance between devotion and individuality.

Previously Seen In: The O.C., Ready or Not, Jennifer’s Body

Where to Watch Adam Brody on Netflix: My Father’s Dragon

Which Supporting Characters Shine in Season 2?

Justine Lupe as Morgan: Can Love Find Her Too?

Joanne’s sister Morgan, played by Justine Lupe, brings humor and heart to the series. Last season, she served as the observer of Joanne’s whirlwind romance. Now, she’s searching for meaning in her own life and perhaps love in unexpected places.

Lupe shares that Morgan begins the season yearning for something more. Her journey embodies the relatable quest for connection while maintaining self-worth.

Previously Seen In: Succession, Mr. Mercedes, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

Where to Watch Justine Lupe on Netflix: Luckiest Girl Alive

Timothy Simons as Sasha: Can Friendship Complicate Family?

Noah’s brother Sasha, played by Timothy Simons, steps into the spotlight with a more complex storyline. His friendship with Morgan causes tension in his marriage, pushing him to reassess his boundaries and priorities.

Simons portrays Sasha as a man trying to repair what might not be broken — but who still can’t shake his guilt. His performance captures the messiness of midlife introspection.

Previously Seen In: Veep, The Handmaid’s Tale, Don’t Worry Darling

Where to Watch Timothy Simons on Netflix: The Twits, Irreplaceable You

Jackie Tohn as Esther: Is It Her Turn to Have Fun?

Jackie Tohn’s Esther, Sasha’s wife, brings humor and self-discovery to the new season. Once the strict half of her marriage, Esther begins to loosen up and rediscover her joy. Learning about Sasha’s closeness with Morgan sparks insecurity, but it also becomes a catalyst for her personal awakening.

As Tohn puts it, Esther decides she’s done being the responsible one all the time — it’s her turn to have fun.

Previously Seen In: GLOW, Best Leftovers Ever!, A Futile and Stupid Gesture

Where to Watch Jackie Tohn on Netflix: GLOW, Best Leftovers Ever!

Which Familiar Faces Return in Season 2?

Michael Hitchcock as Henry: The Advice-Seeking Dad

Michael Hitchcock reprises his role as Henry, Joanne and Morgan’s father. Always full of questions about love, Henry turns to Noah for wisdom. Their exchanges add humor and warmth, highlighting the series’ generational themes.

Previously Seen In: Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, EXmas

Where to Watch Michael Hitchcock on Netflix: Bridesmaids, Mascots

Stephanie Faracy as Lynn: The Spiritual Awakening

Stephanie Faracy returns as Lynn, the matriarch who surprises her daughters by embracing a spiritual side of her own. Her storyline subtly mirrors Joanne’s journey — both women are rediscovering belief systems they once questioned.

Previously Seen In: Uncoupled, Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates

Paul Ben-Victor as Ilan: The Accepting Father

Paul Ben-Victor’s Ilan, Noah and Sasha’s father, continues to be a grounding presence. His easy acceptance of Joanne stands in contrast to his wife’s reservations, adding texture to the family’s dynamic.

Previously Seen In: The Wire, The Irishman

Where to Watch Paul Ben-Victor on Netflix: Monster, The Irishman

Tovah Feldshuh as Bina: Can a Mother’s Heart Change?

As Noah and Sasha’s mother, Bina (Tovah Feldshuh) remains deeply rooted in her faith. Initially resistant to Joanne’s relationship with Noah, she slowly begins to see why her son loves her. Feldshuh’s performance captures the slow thawing of maternal judgment into cautious acceptance.

Previously Seen In: Scenes from a Marriage, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend