Why Are There Two John Cenas in Peacemaker Season 2

Summary:

  • Peacemaker season 2 trailer teases two versions of John Cena’s character, hinting at a multiverse plot.
  • The show may use a dimensional shift to transition from the DCEU to James Gunn’s new DCU.
  • A key theory suggests one Peacemaker might kill the other to take his place in the DCU.

The first trailer for Peacemaker season 2 reveals surprising developments, including a shocking encounter between two versions of John Cena’s Christopher Smith. With the DC Universe undergoing a creative reset under James Gunn, this twist could be the perfect narrative tool to explain how the series jumps from the DCEU to the DCU without losing its continuity.

Why Does Peacemaker Season 2 Feature Two John Cenas?

Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max
Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max

The Peacemaker season 2 trailer closes with a stunning visual: two versions of Christopher Smith—one fully suited and armed, the other in underwear—face each other in a moment of high tension. This suggests a multiverse element is at play, potentially marking the first such storyline in the early phases of James Gunn’s new DCU.

Throughout the trailer, Cena’s Peacemaker appears to be searching for purpose after the events of season 1. He attempts to join a new group, Maxwell Lord’s Justice Gang, while interacting with characters previously confirmed for the DCU, such as Guy Gardner (Nathan Fillion) and Hawkgirl (Isabela Merced). Despite these new connections, it’s the visual cue on his uniform—the dove emblem facing up—that most strongly hints at a different universe version of the character.

In season 1, the emblem was inverted, subtly indicating that the suited Peacemaker seen at the end of the trailer is not the same as the underwear-clad one we’ve followed before. This small design choice provides a visual shorthand for viewers to distinguish between the DCEU and DCU versions of the character.

READ MORE: Final Destination Bloodlines Full Cast and Characters Guide

How Could Peacemaker Transition from the DCEU to the DCU?

Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max
Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max

A major question for fans has been how Peacemaker, initially set in the DCEU, can now exist in the revamped DCU. James Gunn previously acknowledged this concern and promised there would be a clear explanation that ties everything together. The trailer hints that the solution might involve multiversal travel facilitated by a familiar element from season 1: the pocket dimension closet built by Peacemaker’s father.

In the trailer, Christopher Smith steps through this door and emerges in an unfamiliar world—an ideal setup for universe-hopping. If the show confirms this mechanism, it would be the first time in the DCU that a character physically transitions between timelines. This approach allows Peacemaker to keep his DCEU past while functioning in the DCU moving forward.

Further supporting this transition is the inclusion of Frank Grillo as Rick Flag Sr., linking the show to Creature Commandos and Superman—the DCU’s early entries. These connections help establish a unified timeline even as characters move across universes.

READ MORE: The Rookie Season 7 Final Episode Full Breakdown

What Theory Suggests One Peacemaker Might Kill the Other?

Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max
Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max

A popular theory inspired by the trailer suggests that the DCEU version of Peacemaker may kill his DCU counterpart to take his place. This twist would give the existing Peacemaker—along with his established history and character development—a seamless way to continue in the new canon without confusing audiences.

The fact that both Peacemakers appear disoriented in the trailer supports this theory. It’s not a time-travel scenario but rather a collision of realities. Using the pocket dimension, the DCEU’s Christopher Smith could have crossed over and is now faced with his DCU double. The moment of confrontation, with a gun drawn, adds dramatic weight to the possibility that only one version will survive.

This narrative device could also explore themes of identity, sacrifice, and rebirth, giving the show a darker tone while aligning with the franchise’s legacy of violent, morally ambiguous storytelling.

READ MORE: Will Trent Season 3 Last Episode Ending Explained

When Will Peacemaker Season 2 Release and How Is It Connected to the DCU?

Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max
Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max

Peacemaker season 2 is scheduled for release in 2025 on Max. It marks one of the early live-action entries under the James Gunn-led DCU, following Creature Commandos and Superman.

The show also includes appearances by Hawkgirl and Green Lantern Guy Gardner, who are confirmed DCU characters. By bringing in Frank Grillo’s Rick Flag Sr., first seen in Creature Commandos, the show strengthens its ties to the wider universe Gunn is constructing.

Given how the Peacemaker character originated in The Suicide Squad—a DCEU title—season 2 has a dual function: to tell a compelling story and to serve as a bridge between two major phases of the DC franchise.

READ MORE: Final Destination Bloodlines Age Rating and Parental Guide

Will Peacemaker Season 2 Fully Embrace the Multiverse?

Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max
Peacemaker Season 2 _ Official Teaser _ Max

While James Gunn has not explicitly confirmed the use of the multiverse in Peacemaker season 2, all signs point in that direction. His statements in early 2024 assured fans that there is a clear plan to transition the character. The trailer’s visuals, the return of the pocket dimension, and the presence of multiple Peacemakers all reinforce this theory.

If executed well, this could be the DCU’s most elegant solution to its continuity challenge—preserving beloved characters like Peacemaker while resetting the larger universe. The multiverse allows for flexible storytelling without dismissing prior narratives, giving both long-time fans and new viewers a reason to stay invested.

Source: ScreenRant

Stay updated with the Latest News and Stories, follow us on our social media platforms.

You can follow us on:

Pinterest

X

Instagram

Threads

Facebook

Youtube

Stay Connected!! Join our Whatsapp Channel

Enjoying our stories?
Share them with the world!

Quickly spread the word on social media with a click. Your support helps us grow and reach more like-minded folks. Thanks for sharing! 

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured Articles

Follow us Here !!!

Gaming
Movies
TV Series
Consent Preferences