Summary:
-
We Were Liars Episode 5 reveals Johnny violently attacked a student named Delgado and covered it up with his family’s help.
-
Johnny’s hidden romantic feelings for his rival Blake Beaumont added emotional tension to his arc.
-
The series confirms Johnny’s sexuality but his story ends tragically in the Clairmont mansion fire.
Amazon Prime Video’s We Were Liars centers around Cadence Sinclair Eastman’s memory loss, but Episode 5 turns the spotlight on Johnny Sinclair Dennis. While charming and rebellious, Johnny’s past at school reveals a darker side. As part of the Sinclair family’s legacy, his actions reflect the consequences of wealth, secrecy, and emotional repression—elements that ultimately define his tragic arc.
What Did Johnny Do at School in We Were Liars?
In Episode 5 of We Were Liars, Johnny Sinclair Dennis is revealed to have committed a violent act that altered his life and damaged his reputation among his peers. During a school tennis tournament, Johnny and his teammates discovered that the opposing team—led by Blake Beaumont—had vandalized their lockers.
In retaliation, Johnny and his friends flooded the rival team’s tennis court. However, a student named Delgado caught them in the act. Rather than face consequences, Johnny assaulted Delgado, leaving him injured and exposed to the elements. Delgado was later hospitalized.
Fearing exposure, Johnny confessed to his mother, Carrie Sinclair, who quickly intervened. She paid off Delgado’s family, the school, and medical professionals to cover up the incident. This act of bribery ensured the Sinclair family name remained untarnished, but it also highlighted how their wealth enabled them to escape accountability.
The incident reveals a major theme of the series: the Sinclairs’ pattern of denial and image preservation. Johnny’s violent outburst and the family’s concealment of it show how far they are willing to go to suppress the truth. The consequences, however, linger beneath the surface and foreshadow the emotional unraveling that follows.
READ MORE: Liza Koshy Character in KPop Demon Hunters Explained
Is Johnny Gay in We Were Liars and What Complicated His Feelings?
Johnny’s sexuality is a crucial component of his character arc in We Were Liars. The series confirms that Johnny is gay, and his romantic interest in Blake Beaumont—the same rival involved in the locker room incident—adds further complexity to his actions and motivations.
Johnny admits to his friends—known as the Liars—that his rivalry with Blake was intensified by underlying romantic feelings. However, this internal conflict becomes more difficult to navigate when Johnny discovers that Mirren, his cousin and fellow Liar, has been secretly texting Blake all summer.
This emotional triangle adds layers to Johnny’s turmoil. Not only is he harboring unspoken feelings for Blake, but those feelings are now entangled with betrayal by someone close to him. The situation worsens when it’s revealed that Blake recorded Johnny’s assault on Delgado and threatened to blackmail the Sinclairs by releasing the footage online.
Although the series never clarifies whether Blake ultimately shares the video, the threat alone increases the tension and guilt Johnny carries. The unresolved conflict prevents Johnny from expressing or exploring his identity further.
Tragically, Johnny dies in the fire that destroys Clairmont, the Sinclair family estate. His death cuts short any chance for redemption or reconciliation, leaving viewers with a heartbreaking portrait of a young man burdened by secrecy and suppressed identity.
READ MORE: The Waterfront: What Happened to Harlan’s Father?
When Did We Were Liars Premiere and Who Stars in the Cast?
We Were Liars premiered on Amazon Prime Video as an eight-episode limited series. The show is based on the best-selling novel by E. Lockhart and adapted for television by Julie Plec (The Vampire Diaries) and Carina Adly MacKenzie (Roswell, New Mexico).
The cast includes:
-
Emily Alyn Lind as Cadence Sinclair Eastman
-
Esther McGregor as Mirren Sinclair Dennis
-
Joseph Zada as Johnny Sinclair Dennis
-
Shubham Maheshwari as Gat Patil
The series explores memory, guilt, family dysfunction, and identity through a mysterious and emotionally layered narrative. Johnny’s storyline, in particular, offers a poignant look into internalized struggles within the Sinclair family’s privileged but fractured world.
Stay updated with the Latest News and Stories, follow us on our social media platforms.
You can follow us on:
Stay Connected!! Join our Whatsapp Channel
