Summary:
-
We Were Liars Episode 3 confirms Rosemary Sinclair died young and was erased from family memory.
-
The Sinclair family ignored their grief to preserve their public image.
-
The prequel novel Family of Liars reveals Rosemary drowned at age 10 in 1986.
Amazon Prime Video’s We Were Liars follows Cadence Sinclair Eastman’s journey to recover her lost memories, but the series also reveals tragic family secrets buried by the wealthy Sinclair clan. One of the most haunting revelations comes in Episode 3, when the show confirms what happened to Rosemary Sinclair—the family’s youngest and most forgotten daughter.
Who Is Rosemary Sinclair in We Were Liars, and How Did She Die?
We Were Liars introduces Rosemary Sinclair as the youngest child of Harris and Tipper Sinclair, making her the youngest sister of Carrie, Penny, and Bess. Though largely absent from the family’s narrative, Rosemary’s story surfaces in scattered memories and quiet conversations, highlighting the Sinclairs’ tendency to bury emotional truth.
In Episode 2, Carrie Sinclair mentions that none of the sisters were their father’s favorite—except Rosemary. Harris Sinclair, the family patriarch, still watches an old video of Rosemary’s 8th birthday, suggesting unresolved grief despite the family’s silence on the matter.
The events of Episode 3 center around Tipper Sinclair’s funeral. During a discussion between Penny and Cadence, Penny confirms that the family deliberately chose to erase Rosemary from conversation. Their mother, Tipper, had advised them to avoid discussing the tragedy and maintain a composed, unaffected front.
Penny’s recollection reveals that Rosemary died when she was very young, likely before or just after her 11th birthday. The lack of acknowledgment from the Sinclairs paints a picture of emotional suppression, where grief is seen as weakness and family image takes precedence over healing.
READ MORE: The Waterfront: What Happened to Harlan’s Father?
What Caused Rosemary Sinclair’s Death in We Were Liars?
While We Were Liars does not provide full details on Rosemary’s death within the series, E. Lockhart’s prequel novel Family of Liars fills in the gaps. According to the book, Rosemary died at age 10 in August 1986 after drowning in the ocean.
At the time of the accident, Rosemary was under the supervision of Agata, the family’s 20-year-old au pair. During a change in weather, Agata went indoors to retrieve sweaters, leaving Rosemary alone near the water. By the time Agata returned, Rosemary had already entered the ocean and was caught in violent waves caused by the approaching rain. She drowned before help could arrive.
Despite the tragedy, the Sinclair family held no memorial service. Carrie, Penny, and Bess returned to school as if nothing had occurred. This collective silence was in line with Tipper’s philosophy of moving forward without acknowledging pain.
Though Tipper maintained emotional control, the series subtly shows that Harris Sinclair has not fully come to terms with his daughter’s death. His private moments—such as watching old home videos—suggest a deep, unspoken sorrow.
This incident stands as a prime example of the Sinclair family’s flawed values. By prioritizing appearances over truth, they erased Rosemary from memory, turning a personal tragedy into a hidden stain. Cadence, through her growing awareness, begins to see the cracks in the Sinclair façade, including the emotional cost of denying their past.
READ MORE: Liza Koshy Character in KPop Demon Hunters Explained
When Did We Were Liars Release, and Who Stars in the Series?
We Were Liars premiered on June 18, 2025, on Amazon Prime Video. The eight-episode psychological mystery is based on the acclaimed novel by E. Lockhart and was adapted for television by Julie Plec (The Vampire Diaries) and Carina Adly MacKenzie (Roswell, New Mexico).
The main cast includes:
-
Emily Alyn Lind as Cadence Sinclair Eastman
-
Esther McGregor as Mirren Sinclair Dennis
-
Joseph Zada as Johnny Sinclair Dennis
-
Shubham Maheshwari as Gat Patil
-
Candice King, Caitlin Fitzgerald, Rahul Kohli, and David Morse in supporting roles
The series combines memory loss, family trauma, and emotional revelation, weaving together the events of Summer 16 and long-buried secrets like Rosemary’s death.
Stay updated with the Latest News and Stories, follow us on our social media platforms.
You can follow us on:
Stay Connected!! Join our Whatsapp Channel
